01 Evidence & Methods
Each Source Has a Different Leader
Where each chart’s numbers come from, in one card per chart. The full calculations are in the files named on each card.
The charts
The most downloaded open models of the year
- What it shows
- The 15 most downloaded repositories over twelve monthly readings, October 2025 to September 2026.
- Source
- Hugging Face 30-day download counters (hub-stats, read on the 1st of each month); the ATOM Project list of open models (Apache-2.0).
- How we calculated it
- We sum the twelve 30-day readings of each first-party repository, each reading capped at five times the model’s own median month.
- Main limit
- A download is a request for a file, not a user; community conversions and fine-tunes are not added in.
- Files
analysis/ecosystem/top_models_12m.csv·pipelines/ecosystem/top_models_12m.py
Who builds the downloaded models
- What it shows
- Monthly share of downloads by the developer’s headquarters, August 2024 to October 2026.
- Source
- Hugging Face hub-stats; region labels from the ATOM Project.
- How we calculated it
- Monthly 30-day counters for the 1,676 tracked models with downloads, capped as above, grouped by the developer’s headquarters.
- Main limit
- The list is built from models that already succeeded; headquarters is not where the downloads come from.
- Files
visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_1_data.csv·analysis/ecosystem/audit_geo_sensitivity.csv
What Qwen’s downloads are made of, and the size of the models
- What it shows
- Qwen’s downloads by generation and by size band, and Qwen’s share of each size band.
- Source
- Hugging Face hub-stats; parameter counts from the ATOM Project.
- How we calculated it
- The October 2026 reading split by generation and by total parameters.
- Main limit
- Sizes are ATOM’s records; where ATOM has none, the model name.
- Files
analysis/ecosystem/qwen_breakdown_monthly.csv·analysis/ecosystem/size_p29/qwen_lead_by_band_2026_10.csv
The same developers, three measurements
- What it shows
- Downloads on Hugging Face against tokens on OpenRouter and inferences on Cloudflare Workers AI.
- Source
- Hugging Face hub-stats; OpenRouter rankings (CC BY 4.0); Cloudflare Radar, Workers AI (with Cloudflare’s permission).
- How we calculated it
- Each developer’s share in each source, for the nearest common month.
- Main limit
- Three platforms with different users and units; none is the whole market.
- Files
analysis/ecosystem/platform_signals.csv
What gets built on top, and what papers name
- What it shows
- Derivative repositories declared on Hugging Face, and research papers that name a model family.
- Source
- Hugging Face hub-stats derivatives extract (22 October 2026); OpenAlex (CC0).
- How we calculated it
- Derivatives counted by the family of their declared base model; papers by the family named in title or abstract.
- Main limit
- A declared base is the uploader’s claim; a mention is not evidence that a paper used the model.
- Files
analysis/ecosystem/derivatives_by_family.csv·visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_2_data.csv
More data
Figures from the research that the chapter’s charts do not show.
- Files made for local runtimes sit in separate repositories that the main download count leaves out. In ATOM’s list of such conversions, Qwen’s drew another 134.5 million uncapped downloads in the 30 days to 1 October 2026, 37% of its total once they are added, against 36% for Google’s.
- Weight files on Hugging Face: Qwen3-0.6B, 1.5 GB; Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct, 15.2 GB; Qwen3-8B, 16.4 GB; Gemma 4 26B-A4B, 51.6 GB; DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731, 166.9 GB; Kimi K3, 1,561 GB. Qwen and Google publish their own builds for local runtimes; none were found for the DeepSeek and Moonshot models.
Sources and notes
Show the 34 notes
Evidence levels: E1 = figure published by the source; E3 = computed by us from the source data, with no published counterpart (reproducible pipeline and tests). Every figure in this chapter is E3. Download and derivative data: cfahlgren1/hub-stats (Apache-2.0), monthly snapshots and the snapshot of 2026-10-22, revisions and checksums in data/manifests/hubstats_2026-10-22.json. Model list and region labels: ATOM Project tracked-models at commit d4b170903ec3 (Apache-2.0), data/raw/atom_tracked/d4b170903ec3/. Mentions: OpenAlex (CC0), recounted 2026-10-26, data/raw/openalex/audit_2026-10-26/. Definitions follow DEC-102 to DEC-106, each as amended by its revision 1 of 2026-10-26 (research/decisions.md). Every number in the text is listed with its source in research/editorial/sprint25/ch01-claims.csv.
- 1
analysis/ecosystem/top_models_12m.csv(pipelines/ecosystem/top_models_12m.py): downloads summed over the twelve 30-day readings of 1 November 2025 to 1 October 2026 (about 360 counted days), the same population and cap as figure 1.1;developers_12m.csvfor the developers' and regions' shares (Qwen 0.54; US-based developers 0.31; China-based 0.66). The window and family rankings without Qwen:top_models_windows.csv,families_no_qwen_windows.csv. - 2
visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_1_data.csv, rows 2024-08 and 2026-10, capped series (each model at five times its own median month): China-based 0.17 and 0.68; Qwen 0.10 and 0.55; US-based 0.69 and 0.30. Same values inanalysis/ecosystem/audit_geo_sensitivity.csv, variantcapped_5x_median (E1, baseline). List size: 1,840 rows indata/raw/atom_tracked/d4b170903ec3/models.csv(studied_ids.atomin the manifest). "About a fifth" for August 2024 covers the capped (17.2%) and uncapped (23.7%) readings (DEC-103 rev. 1). E3. - 3
qwen_breakdown_monthly.csv, 2026-10:size_band_total(under 10B 0.72, 10–40B 0.24, 40B and above 0.03, unknown 0.01),size_band_active(under 10B 0.80),architecture(dense 0.88, MoE 0.11),precision(first-party quantised 0.12; 2025-10: 0.02),specialisation(named vision-language 0.17, coding 0.04).analysis/ecosystem/qwen_size_bands.csv, basistotal, Qwen's share of each band: 0.67, 0.52, 0.14 (812, 337 and 342 tracked models with parameter data). Sizes: ATOMmetadata__model_parameters.csvatd4b1709(total parameters; active where ATOM gives them, otherwise total for dense models; for Qwen3.5 and later the count excludes the vision encoder).analysis/ecosystem/qwen_top_models.csv, rank 1;qwen_concentration_monthly.csv, 2026-10:models_for_half10,models_for_80pct29. Image input of Qwen3.5-397B-A17B and Qwen3.8-27B: their Hugging Face model cards, read 2026-11-07. No share of all vision-language downloads is computed: the list has no modality field, and other developers' repository names do not mark it consistently. E3. Per-model rankings (section The Most Downloaded Models):pipelines/ecosystem/top_models.py, same population, cap and reading as Figure 1.1 (the 1,676 models with capped downloads above zero);analysis/ecosystem/top_models_2026_10.csv(the ten together 0.30 of tracked downloads;Qwen/Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instructcapped, raw 8,703,304),top_models_by_developer_2026_10.csv,top_models_developers_2026_10.csv(rank_of_best_model_in_all_tracked: Moonshot AI 64, DeepSeek 21). Dates: ATOMmetadata__release_date_corrections.csv, otherwisecreatedAtin the pinned hub-stats derivatives extract of 2026-10-22, otherwisesources/model_reference_2026.csv. E3. - 4
analysis/ecosystem/qwen_breakdown_monthly.csv, dimensiongeneration, 2026-10,share_of_qwen: Qwen3 0.45, Qwen2.5 0.24, Qwen3.5 0.15, Qwen3.6 0.07, Qwen3.8 0.06; the rest 0.02. Generation from Qwen's own repository names (pipelines/ecosystem/qwen_composition.py,generation). Growth:analysis/ecosystem/qwen_growth_by_generation.csv: Qwen's capped downloads 77,824,476 (2025-10) and 224,031,936 (2026-10); Qwen3's part of the net change 0.49. Same population, readings and cap as figure 1.1; the module reproduces 0.10 and 0.55 before computing anything. E3. - 5Hugging Face model API (
/api/models/<id>?blobs=true), each repository'sconfig.jsonand model card at the pinned commit, and Qwen's, Google's, DeepSeek's and Moonshot AI's own repositories searched by name, retrieved 2026-11-08 (research/editorial/interpretation-pass28/data/hf_api/, manifest with commit hashes;scripts/fetch_hf_models.py,scripts/qwen_hardware.py, outputdata/qwen_hardware.csv). Parameters: ATOM's metadata, as in the rest of the chapter (Hugging Face's own count of stored parameters differs: 0.75 billion for Qwen3-0.6B, which counts the embedding table). Weight files: the summed size of the repository's weight files on the Hub. Developer's own builds: repositories under the developer's namespace whose names mark FP8, AWQ, GPTQ, GGUF or MLX; "none found" means none under that namespace on the retrieval date, not none anywhere. The 4 GB is a theoretical, weight-only figure (8.19 billion parameters x 0.5 bytes), not the memory a runtime needs. Runtimes: as named in the model cards of Qwen3-0.6B and Qwen3-8B. - 6
research/editorial/interpretation-pass28/scripts/local_formats.py, outputdata/local_formats_2026_10.csv: the hub-stats snapshot of 2026-10-01 (data/raw/hubstats/tracked_2026-10.csv) and ATOM'slocal-models.csvatd4b1709(1,627 curated conversions, each credited to its parent), throughpipelines.ecosystem.analysis.labels(). Uncapped 30-day counts, the population of the chapter's "with local conversions" sensitivity. Qwen: 228,951,136 on its tracked repositories; 26,572,840 on its own local-format repositories (AWQ, GGUF, GPTQ) and 107,956,154 on others' (GGUF 47,425,982; MLX 23,841,944, among others), 37.0% of the total. Google: 45,141,149 and 24,989,587, 35.6%. ATOM's list is a curated selection, not every conversion on the Hub, and a download of a GGUF file is a file request like any other, not evidence of local inference. E3. - 7
fig1_1_data.csv, columnsshare_china,share_us,share_eu: Europe-based 0.12 (2024-08) and 0.02 (2026-10). China-based share ≥ US-based share in 2024-11 (0.47 vs 0.47), 2024-12 (0.49 vs 0.46) and in every month from 2025-08; China-based share 0.65–0.69 from 2026-02 to 2026-10. "Two-thirds" and "about a fifth" are used only with this population and the capped calculation (DEC-103 rev. 1). E3. - 8Qwen's models: 208 rows with organisation
Qweninmodels.csv.fig1_1_data.csv,share_qwen_of_all: 0.10 (2024-08), 0.55 (2026-10); 0.55 / 0.68 = 0.81. E3. - 9
analysis/ecosystem/audit_geo_sensitivity.csv, variantscapped_without_Qwen(2026-10: China-based 0.29, US-based 0.66, 1,469 models) andcapped_fixed_panel_2024-08(2024-08: 0.17; 2026-10: 0.23).analysis/ecosystem/audit_geo_lodo.csv: 2026-10 China-based share without Google 0.77, without DeepSeek 0.66; largest move among developers other than Qwen: Google, +8.5 points. Without Qwen, 2024-08: China-based 0.09 (audit_geo_lodo.csv, rowQwen); by developer, share of the downloads without Qwen, 2024-08 to 2026-10: DeepSeek 0.02 to 0.14, Z.ai 0 to 0.07, all other China-based developers together 0.07 to 0.09 (analysis/ecosystem/audit_geo_without_qwen_by_developer.csv, Pass 26). Alternative populations, not intervals (DEC-103 rev. 1). E3. - 10
audit_geo_sensitivity.csv, 2026-10:raw0.67;in_month_allTime_delta0.67;with_local_conversions_raw0.70;raw_without_month_top10_models0.64;capped_contested_orgs_relabelled0.68. 2024-08: capped 0.17, raw 0.24, without top 10 0.33.research/ecosystem-audit.md§2. DEC-103 rev. 1. E3. - 11
analysis/ecosystem/downloads_monthly.csv,first_party, developermistralai: 3,052,532 (2024-12) and 60,893,655 (2025-01). Cause not verified; question prepared for Hugging Face, not sent.research/ecosystem-feasibility.md§1. DEC-103 rev. 1. E3. - 12ATOM
tracked-modelsREADME (data/raw/atom_tracked/d4b170903ec3/README.md), scope and threshold; region mapmetadata__organization_regions.csv(121 organisations). ATOM'seuvalue is a Europe-facing bucket, not a claim of EU membership. Source labels are kept apart fromregistry/model_openness.csv(DEC-105). Hugging Face'sregion:ustag denotes storage location (research/ecosystem-sources.md§2.2). DEC-102 rev. 1, DEC-103 rev. 1. E1. - 13
analysis/ecosystem/qwen_openrouter_namespace.csv, 2026-09: 0.01 (versions whose identifier beginsqwen/, over the tokens of the 50 most-used versions, the "Others" bucket excluded;data/processed/openrouter/daily_rankings.csv, Chapter 03's data). Not combined with downloads (DEC-105 rev. 1). E3. - 14
pipelines/ecosystem/platform_signals.py,analysis/ecosystem/platform_signals.csv(=visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_5_data.csv):hf_share(chapter 01's capped 2026-10 reading, 1,676 models),or_open_share(September 2026 tokens of versions with an OW-P, OW-R or OW-N class in the effective registry, 64.9% of top-50 tokens; DeepSeek 0.35, Tencent 0.20, Z.ai 0.18, Qwen 0.01),cf_share(analysis/cloudflare-s11/within_task_rankings_monthly.csv, Text Generation, 2026-10; Meta 0.29). Developers are matched by namespace on each platform (DEVELOPERSin the module); a namespace is a publisher, not a model family. Workers AI offers no model from MiniMax, Tencent or Xiaomi. DEC-105 rev. 1: not combined. E3. - 15DEC-105 rev. 1: downloads, tokens on an intermediary, mentions and bot traffic are not combined or normalised against each other.
research/ecosystem-feasibility.md§2. - 16
analysis/ecosystem/audit_two_windows.csv, 2026-09,baseline: n = 35, ρ = 0.05, bootstrap 95% −0.32 to 0.37, permutation p = 0.79. Coverage:analysis/ecosystem/audit_two_windows_selection.csv(0.67; 0.32 identified with no public weights repository; 0.01 unresolved). Ranks:visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_3_data.csv. OpenRouter rankings data, CC BY 4.0 (Chapter 03). DEC-105 rev. 1. E3. - 17
analysis/ecosystem/e3_identity_review.csv(44 variants; reviewer "Claude (agent) from the captured evidence; human confirmation pending"). Confirmed only:audit_two_windows.csv, variantidentity review: confirmed matches only, n = 29, ρ = 0.07, −0.31 to 0.43. Monthly baseline 2025-01 to 2026-09: ρ from −0.39 (2025-12) to 0.38 (2025-04), the only two months whose interval excludes zero (research/ecosystem-audit.md§4). Figure 1.3 statusinternalindesign/figure-registry.json. E3. - 18
data/manifests/hubstats_2026-10-22.json,derivatives: snapshot revisiona686672(2026-10-22), 3,177,876 Hub model repositories, 902,524 declaring a base. Total: sum ofreposinanalysis/ecosystem/derivatives_by_family.csvandderivatives_monthly.csv, both 470,289, checked bytests/test_chapter01_s20b.py. The source snapshot lists one repository twice (neko-legends/GLM-5.3-Flash-Uncensored-EXL3); counted once, as recorded in the manifest (duplicate_ids_in_source). Earlier records give 470,290 before de-duplication. Relations are inferred by the Hub from the uploader's declaration. DEC-106 rev. 1. E3. - 19
derivatives_by_family.csv, columnsreposanddistinct_accounts; 229,596 / 470,289 = 0.49. Family = the base model's developer namespace, with former namespaces merged (pipelines/ecosystem/analysis.py,FAMILY_ALIASES). E3. - 20
derivatives_by_family.csv,high_volume_share: Qwen 0.34, Google 0.44, Meta 0.12;largest_account_reposfor Qwen: 12,205. High-volume = an account with at least 1,000 derivative repositories across the whole extract (analysis.HIGH_VOLUME). DEC-106 rev. 1. E3. - 21
derivatives_by_year_region.csv, 2024–2026, China and US rows:repos,distinct_accounts,repos_excl_high_volume(2024 China: 80,928 − 22,353 = 58,575 from high-volume accounts). Adapters:derivatives_monthly.csv, months 2024-01 to 2024-12,base_regionchina,relationadapter: 73,693. Roots:analysis/ecosystem/derivatives_by_root.csv. Accounts can publish derivatives of several regions' models, so account counts are not summed across regions. 2026 runs to 22 October. E3. - 22
derivatives_monthly.csv, sum ofrepos_ge5_downloads: 402,104 (402,105 inresearch/ecosystem-audit.md, before de-duplication). E3. - 23OpenAlex works API (CC0),
title_and_abstract.search; family terms and co-term inpipelines/ecosystem/openalex.py(CO,FAMILIES). The GPT/ChatGPT rule includes ChatGPT, GPT-3.5, GPT-4, GPT-4o, GPT-5, o1 and o3; without o1 and o3, its 2025 share of all language-model works is 13.1% rather than 13.6% (research/ecosystem-audit.md§3). DEC-104 rev. 1. - 24
visualizations/ecosystem/fig1_2_data.csv, columnsworks_naming_any_family,all_llm_works,share_of_naming_worksandshare_of_all_llm_works; counts and denominators from the same day (2026-10-26). Llama, share of all language-model works: 0.02 (2023), 0.05 (2024), 0.05 (2025). Counts from 2026-10-22 differ by up to 0.3%. DEC-104 rev. 1. E3. - 25Sum of the 14 counted families (
pipelines/ecosystem/openalex_audit.py,COUNTED) overany_family, fromdata/raw/openalex/audit_2026-10-26/: 36,273 / 23,494 = 1.54 in 2025. Checked bytests/test_chapter01_s20b.py(test_mentions_overlap_and_ambiguous_families_stay_out). E3. - 26
analysis/ecosystem/hub_share.csv,first_party_share: 0.02 (2024-08) and 0.14 (2026-10). Selection bias:research/ecosystem-feasibility.md§1 (H1, "Sesgos"). E3. - 271,676:
fig1_1_data.csv, columnmodels, 2026-10 (models with a non-zero capped reading; 1,684 uncapped inaudit_geo_sensitivity.csv, variantraw). 486 and 441:audit_geo_sensitivity.csv, variantcapped_fixed_panel_2024-08(note andmodelscolumn, 2024-08); 390 of the 486 have downloads in 2026-10. Before the cap (variantraw), 444 models had downloads in 2024-08. The cap uses each model's median month, zero months included, so a model whose median month is zero is capped to zero; the shares do not change (Pass 26, independent review A-02). The figure of 1,840 in DEC-106 is the list size; it is not the number of models with downloads in a given month. E3. - 28Download definition: Hugging Face, "Models download stats" (summarised in
research/ecosystem-sources.md§2.1). Field availability:research/ecosystem-sources.md§2.3. Comparison:analysis/ecosystem/audit_counters.csv, columnratio_30d_over_delta: 0.89–1.02 in the 15 months other than 2025-06 (11.50), 2025-07 (0.57), 2026-05 (1.40) and 2026-06 (0.76); decreases summed fromallTime_decreases(18) andallTime_decrease_sum(2026-02: −4,319,803). The cumulative counter's freeze is consistent with an import gap documented in thehub-statsREADME; the 2026 anomaly is unexplained and is among the questions prepared for Hugging Face (research/partner-requests-s20.md). DEC-103 rev. 1. E3. - 29
data/raw/hubstats/tracked_2026-05.csv,Qwen/Qwen3-VL-2B-Instruct,downloads185,757,734 (snapshot of 2026-05-01).fig1_1_data.csv, 2026-05:share_china_raw0.77,share_china0.68. E3. - 30
derivatives_by_year_region.csv, sum of the 2023 rows across regions: 3,073.derivatives_monthly.csv, sums bypath(direct 337,713; indirect 132,576) andrelation. Originals that declare a base: 2,048 tracked models (manifestrows_kept472,337 − 470,289); 362 derivatives uploaded by the base model's own developer are marked separately and included. Longest chain: manifestmax_depth16.research/ecosystem-audit.md§5. E3. - 31
research/ecosystem-feasibility.md§1 (H2, "Línea base" and "No se usa texto completo"). E3. - 32
analysis/ecosystem/openalex_precision.csvandopenalex_precision_labels.csv: samples of 20 works from 2025, 16–20 with the name in the returned text; families in Figure 1.2 at 1.00 on matched works (Falcon, not drawn, 0.95); lower Wilson 95% bounds 0.81–0.84 (research/ecosystem-audit.md§3). BLOOM: 9 of 16 in model sense (0.56), excluded. Recall not measured. DEC-104 rev. 1. E3. - 33
research/ecosystem-sources.md§2.1, §1.2 and §4; DEC-102 rev. 1 (Cloudflare Radar data CC BY-NC 4.0; Interconnects/ATOM dashboard cited only) and DEC-102 rev. 2 (Cloudflare Radar's Workers AI data used in Chapter 03 with permission). DEC-101: no organisation is a research partner. - 34
research/partner-requests-s20.md(prepared, not sent). Hugging Face statistics are used as public data (editor, 2026-10-31; DEC-118). Figure statuses fromdesign/figure-registry.json: figures 1.1, 1.1b, 1.2, 1.3, 1.4 and 1.5,provisional.